Historic District of Madison Indiana
Shops In Walking Distance

Red Pepper deli, cafe, catering, and pizza.

Red Pepperoni


Classic Pizzeria

842 W. Main St
Madison IN 47250
Phone: (812) 274-0111
Fax: (812) 274-0309


Eat in or Carry Out


Respect Yourself

There are two kinds of pizza in this world. There’s the pizza of easy opportunity, like at the food court in the mall, in a display case, maybe still warm, maybe made today, maybe not. Maybe it crawled out of a box like those pizza’s at the supermarket. You’re all by yourself. Maybe it’s getting late, you’re thinking about going home all alone and eating ramen noodles all by yourself, again, and it’s last call. Then you wake up the next day, feeling that brick in your stomach, hating yourself and feeling disgusted because you can’t believe you actually ate it. We are your support group, here to help you never fall so low again.


Classic Pizzeria

The other kind is found at
a "Classic Pizzeria," like The Red Pepperoni. All they do is work to perfect the fine art and craft of pizza. No hot dogs (the lowest form of food) and no one day old pizza in a display case. This pizza is made fresh to order! With ingredients grown under the sunshine, not made in a secret government laboratory for drones. This Classic Pizzeria is focused on the quality of the pizza, the atmosphere and the experience of enjoying hot juicy sizzled pepperoni pizza with good people and friends. This is where you’ve been wanting to be, and didn't even know it. Don’t wake up again, in denial, pretending you don’t know where a mysterious empty frozen pizza box came from, how it got in your kitchen, or trying to explain

how someone else left it there. Oh, the shame! Its better to save up, and get out, here, in the real world, with the living. See some smiling faces. Enjoy quality pizza, together at The Red Pepperoni. And most of all, have some fun!


Romantic Date

Notice the beer carton holders on the table. As a man of the world, I have it on good authority that wives & girlfriends wish you were cute, crafty and clever like that. And when you’re looking for a romantic date restaurant, without too much pressure to talk, where you just want to get comfortable with one another, and yourself quite frankly. Unlike an overly sophisticated place, like you don’t really know what you’re doing there, cause you feel 'out of place'. A Classic Pizzeria like The Red Pepperoni is just the place you wanna go.


Large Groups?

Large Party? No problem, just make a reservation in advance. They’ve got the space and resources to serve large parties with seating for about 50 people and dedicated waitresses to serve them. Birthday party, yes. Office retreat, conference meeting, promotion party, or office christmas party? Why not, with a little planning you could probably use the four big flat screen televisions for presentations aids. Think about it! And nothing makes business go down smoother than a nice cold beer (on the menu)! This is the only place you will ever catch me eating pizza downtown in Madison Historic District.


Classic Pizza

842 W. Main St
Madison IN 47250
Phone: (812) 274-0111
Fax: (812) 274-0309


Eat in & Carry Out

Trivia: Suggest a good trivia question a trivia question.


Back to

Visit their official web site here.


Sometimes people think Madison Historic District, also known as Historic Madison, is located in Milton Kentucky, but we are actually located just 1 mile north in Downtown Madison Indiana, across the Harrison Bridge on the north side of the Ohio River.


Walk-About | Lodging | Restaurants | Family Activities | Romance | Attractions
About | Map & Directions | Mobile Services | Sale | Policy & Privacy
Copyright ©2024 Madison Historic District Shops™ and respective authors.
For Corrections & Requests click here.



Map to The Red Pepperoni with the Weather Report

View Larger Map

[ top ]

[ top | menu ]

Appetizers & Starters

Bread Sticks
with marinara, spicy cheese or garlic butter)
Full Order (six)
Cheesy Bread
Chicago fries
with cheese sauce


Toasted Ravioli (six)
Spinach & Artichoke dip
Basket of Fries
Loaded Fries
w/cheese, scallions, bacon & ranch


[ top | menu ]

Custom Pizza


Pepperoni, Sausage, Capicola Ham, Bacon, Chicken, Mushrooms, Sun dried Tomatoes, Onions, Green Peppers, Pineapples, Red Peppers, Green Olives, Banana Pepper, Giardiniera, Jalapenos, Black Olives, Spinach, Extra Cheese, Gouda, Feta Cheese, Cheddar

Personal Pizza

Regular 10 inch

Large 14 inch

each one or additional topping          $0.99 $1.25

[top | menu]

Specialty Pizzas




NO substitutions, additional toppings $1.00 each

Ultimate Veggie Pizza

mushrooms, onions, green and black olives, green peppers

RPD Special Pizza

pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms, green peppers

Mac Daddy Pizza

pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon, and extra cheese

Greek Pizza

fresh garlic, onions, banana peppers, feta cheese, black olives and spinach

BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ Sauce, chicken, green peppers, onions, gouda and mozzarella cheese

Thai Chicken Pizza

Thai peanut sauce, chicken, carrots, red peppers, onions and blend of cheeses

Hawaiian Pizza

bacon, capicola ham, pineapple, and mozzarella

Roasted Artichoke Pizza

Spinach artichoke spread, artichokes, garlic, spinach, mozzarella and parmesan cheese

CBR Pizza

Chicken, Bacon & Ranch sauce and mozzarella

White Pizza

Pesto sauce, sun dried tomatoes, onions, mozzarella, feta cheese, gouda and spinach

Sicilian Pizza

Sausage, capicola ham, salami, pepperoni, spicy giardiniera, parmesan cheese, mozzarella cheese

Hardy Meatball Pizza

chunky meatballs, extra cheese, topped with marinara

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

alfredo sauce, chicken, red peppers, onions, topped with mozzarella

All American Pizza

Ketchup, mustard, ground beef, bacon, mixed cheeses, topped with dill pickles

[top | menu]


$7.95 Choose three toppings
extra toppings $0.50 each

[top | menu]


$6.35 baked on hoagies

Meatball Sub:
meatballs, marinara,

Mad Sicilian Sub:
meatballs, marinara,
spicy giardiniera, mozzarella

Veggie Stromboli:
mushrooms, onions,
green pepper, red peppers,
black olives, mozzarella,

Italian Sub:
Capicola ham, pepperoni,
salami, mozzarella, onions,
lettuce, oil & vinegar

Buffalo Chicken:
buffalo chicken,
crumbled blue cheese,
onions, blue cheese
dressing, lettuce

pepperoni, sausage,
mushrooms, green peppers,
onions, pizza sauce,

[top | menu]


Six / Twelve / Eighteen = $4.99 / $8.50 / $12.50

Sauces: Spicy buffalo, Tangy BBQ, Teriyaki, Chipotle
Served with Blue Cheese or Ranch and Celery.

[top | menu]


Chopped Cobb $6.95

chicken, boiled eggs, avocado, bacon, blue cheese, tomatoes, choice of blue cheese or ranch

Italian Salad $6.95

pepperoni, capicola ham, salami, mozzarella, banana peppers, onions, green olives, artichokes, tomato, tossed with our house dressing

The Wedge $6.35

Iceberg lettuce, onions, blue cheese, tomatoes

Buffalo Chicken $6.35

buffalo chicken, onions, blue cheese crumbles, tomatoes, served with celery sticks

Caesar Salad $5.25

tomatoes, onions, parmesan, tossed in dressing

Garden Salad $2.95

green olives, mozzarella, banana peppers, onions, tossed in house dressing

[ top | menu ]