Historic District of Madison Indiana
Shops In Walking Distance

Enterance dining area at the Red Pepper, Deli, Cafe, Catering and Pizza, 902 W. Main Street, Madison Indiana 47250, 812-265-3354.

Red Pepper

Deli, Cafe
& Catering

902 W. Main Street
Madison IN 47250
Phone: (812) 265-3354


Gourmet sandwiches,
homemade soups, salads,
desserts, coffee, beer, wine.
Specialty Eentrees on
Friday & Saturday nights.

Menu changes weekly.

Please do not throw baskets in trash can. If one falls, let us know. Thank You! Ordering area and menu up this way!


Intimate seating at the Red Pepper, Deli, Cafe, Catering and Pizza, 902 W. Main Street, Madison Indiana 47250, 812-265-3354.

Intimate seating:

One of the first things you notice, is the small private chamber layout of the building. The Red Pepper could easily host 2 small parties, a medium party, plus 2 other large group parties simultaneously. Each area has varying degrees of privacy to choose from, whether you’re planning on a small intimate diner, or a large group. One of the largest areas, the outdoor private deck area, a group could literally be as loud as they want to be, and the other customers would hardly notice. I love the layout of the building, the bold look, and the optional privacy for whatever one had in mind.

restroom facilities Napkins High Chairs are here for a reason,
   you’re welcome to use them!


More private seating at the Red Pepper, Deli, Cafe, Catering and Pizza, 902 W. Main Street, Madison Indiana 47250, 812-265-3354.

level capacity


To the left is another look at the private chamber like dining spaces.



Fresh sunlight,
no extra charge,
during the day only.

Coffe, Tea, Hot Water Soda machine actual red peppers


Large dining room at The Red Pepper, Deli, Cafe, Catering and Pizza, 902 W. Main Street, Madison Indiana 47250, 812-265-3354.

The Large Room:

See the door
to the outside
private deck.

The Red Pepper caters to any size party and not just
sandwiches! Let them
customize a special menu
for your corporate party,
weddings, cocktail parties
and much more!

Door leading out to the private deck area Ceiling fan, in case someone is overcome by the red pepper spices ripe tomato red and yellow bell peppers red onions Caponata (Sicilian ''capunata'') is a Sicilian aubergine or eggplant you tell me what this one is looks like oranges, if not let me know Fire extinguisher, in case food gets too spicy


Outdoors private party deck area at The Red Pepper, Deli, Cafe, Catering and Pizza, 902 W. Main Street, Madison Indiana 47250, 812-265-3354.

Outside Area
Private Deck

Make a reservation for your private party!

seats waiting for you’re reservation secret satelite communicating with NASA Fresh Air,
 real wood,
 and if you do something embarassing,
 only the people out here with you will see. The alien technology NASA is searching for

Trivia: Suggest a good trivia question a trivia question.


Back to

Visit their official web site here.


Sometimes people think Madison Historic District, also known as Historic Madison, is located in Milton Kentucky, but we are actually located just 1 mile north in Downtown Madison Indiana, across the Harrison Bridge on the north side of the Ohio River.


Walk-About | Lodging | Restaurants | Family Activities | Romance | Attractions
About | Map & Directions | Mobile Services | Sale | Policy & Privacy
Copyright ©2024 Madison Historic District Shops™ and respective authors.
For Corrections & Requests click here.




Map to The Red Pepper with the Weather Report

View Larger Map

[top | menu]

  Note: Prices and menu items change. 
Vast and diverse menu at the Red Pepper, Deli, Cafe, Catering and Pizza, 902 W. Main Street, Madison Indiana 47250, 812-265-3354.

Red Pepper

Phone: (812) 265-3354
The second thing you’ll discover, the menu is a lot more elaborate than expected. The Red Pepper is a "full service restaurant."

People come here without knowing what they want, and find new interesting things on the menu when they get here.

I challenge you to find another restaurant which offers peanut butter and jelly! Now that’s full service!

Soup of the Day Wraps Signature sandwiches Grilled Panini sandwiches Grinders Happy Customers! Specials of the Day! Friendly Service Something Delicious

[top | menu]

Signature Sandwiches $6.35

Served with chips and pickle

Hydro Plane – Oven roasted beef, pepper jack cheese, homemade whipped horsey sauce, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes on sourdough

Miss Madison – Roasted turkey breast, cucumber cream cheese, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, mustard on Eurograin wheat

Lanier – Our own creation. Chicken salad with red peppers, scallions, celery in a tarragon mayonnaise served on a croissant

Madisonian – Turkey, ham, roast beef, smoked Cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, mustard on a hoagie

Hanging Rock BBQ – Shredded chicken in a garlic hot BBQ sauce with American cheese and topped with a mountain of homemade cole slaw served on a Kaiser roll

Valley Veggie – Homemade hummus, Cheddar, cucumber cream cheese, spicy brown mustard and as many veggies as we can pile high on Eurograin wheat

Italian – Ham, pepperoni, Genoa salami, mozzarella cheese, creamy Italian, pepperoncini, lettuce, red onions, tomatoes on a hoagie

Charlie’s Original – Tuna salad topped with lettuce, tomato on wheat bread

Santa Fe Turkey – Pepper turkey, Southwest cream cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, pepperoncini on a hoagie

California Club – Turkey, bacon, Swiss cheese, guacamole, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions served on a croissant.

Grilled Panini
Sandwiches $6.35

Delta Queen – Turkey, Cheddar cheese, marinated green peppers
and onions grilled on Italian white bread

Poco – Pepperoni and ham
topped with green peppers,
onions, mozzarella, pizza sauce
and grilled on Italian bread

Texan – Roasted beef, Cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, red onions
grilled on Italian bread

River Reuben – No explanation needed! With kraut, grilled on rye

Pesto Turkey – Fresh pesto, mozzarella, red onions, tomatoes, grilled on Italian white bread

Vampire Slayer – Pastrami,
Swiss, roasted garlic cream cheese, Giardiniera, grilled on rye

venetian Veggie – Fresh pesto, mozzarella, tomatoes, red onions layered on Italian white bread

Tuna Melt – Tuna fish topped
with Cheddar cheese and grilled
on Italian white bread

[top | menu]

Grinders $6.35

Sandwiches baked on fresh baked baguettes. Served with chips and pickle.

Teriyaki Chicken – Grilled chicken, green peppers, onions, Swiss cheese, teriyaki, mayo baked on French bread

Steak Sandwich – Roast beef, Swiss cheese, green peppers, onions, pepperoncini, steak sauce baked on French bread

Fiesta Turkey – Pepper turkey, pepper jack cheese, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onions baked on French bread

Pizza Stromboli Sausage, pepperoni, pizza sauce, pepperoncini, onions, green peppers, mozzarella baked on French bread

Tuscan Turkey – Turkey, bacon, Cheddar, southwest ranch, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions baked on French bread

The New Yorker – True New York pastrami, cream cheese, hot beer mustard, pepperoncini, lettuce, onions baked on French bread

Hammy Grinder – Ham, Swiss, Cheddar, mayo, lettuce, pepperoncini, onions baked on hoagie

of the Day

Mmade fresh daily

Small $2.75
Large $3.50


Choose Two

Choose ½ sandwich or ½ salad with a cup of soup or one of our homemade salads or garden salad. $6.25

[top | menu]


Wraps not available with combos

Chicken Wrap – Grilled chicken, rice, lettuce, salsa, sour cream, cheese wrapped in a flour tortilla

Veggie Wrap – Rice, black beans, guacamole, southwest cream cheese, salsa, cheese, lettuce wrapped in a flour tortilla

Chicken Caesar Wrap – Grilled chicken, parmesan cheese, feta cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and Caesar dressing wrapped in a flour tortilla

BBQ Chicken Wrap – BBQ chicken, cole slaw, onions, cheese wrapped in a flour tortilla

Chicken Pesto Wrap – Grilled chicken, pesto, cream cheese, rice, tomatoes, onions, parmesan cheese and lettuce wrapped in a flour tortilla

Kids Stuff

Served with drink & a treat!

  • Jack’s Jamwich – Peanut butter & jelly on white bread
  • Sam’s Ham – Ham & American cheese on white bread
  • Will’s Grill – Will’s own grilled cheese

[top | menu]

Deli Salads


pasta salads or potato salads, made fresh daily! Call for the selections of the day

Small $2.25
Large $4.50
Sold by the pound

Chef John Salad – Romaine lettuce, Swiss and American cheese, turkey, ham, green peppers, carrots, cucumbers, red onions, tomatoes and homemade croutons. $6.35

Greek Salad – Romaine lettuce, feta cheese, black olives, pepperoncini, cucumbers, red onions, homemade croutons served with Greek dressing. $6.35

Caesar Salad – Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, red onions, tomatoes, homemade croutons served with Caesar dressing. $5.95 Add $1.00 for grilled chicken.